What "pre-tax" means on a paycheck
A pre-tax deduction comes out of your gross pay before some taxes are worked out. Each tax that no longer applies to that money is a tax you don't pay on it now, so your take-home drops by the contribution minus the tax it saved.
Which taxes it skips depends on the type of deduction:
| Deduction | Federal income tax | Social Security and Medicare | State income tax |
|---|---|---|---|
| Traditional 401(k) | Lowered | Not lowered | Lowered in most states; not in Pennsylvania |
| HSA through a cafeteria plan | Lowered | Lowered | Lowered in most states; not in California or New Jersey |
| Health, dental and vision premiums through a cafeteria plan | Lowered | Lowered | Lowered in our figures for all 12 states |
The middle column is the one people miss. A traditional 401(k) contribution still pays Social Security (6.2%) and Medicare (1.45%); HSA contributions and premiums taken through a cafeteria plan do not. So, dollar for dollar, an HSA contribution lowers your take-home by less than a 401(k) contribution.
A Roth 401(k) is not on this list. Roth contributions come out after tax, so every dollar you put in lowers your take-home by a full dollar. Your employer's match does not appear on your paycheck at all: it goes straight to your account and does not reduce or add to your take-home.
What a contribution actually costs you
Here is a single filer earning $60,000, paid biweekly, with each type of deduction on its own and then all three together. "Put in" is what goes to the account or the insurer over the year; "take-home" is what is left after all taxes and deductions.
| Deduction | Put in a year | Take-home in Texas | Take-home in New York | Take-home in Illinois |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| None | $0 | $50,390 | $47,424 | $47,565 |
| 401(k) at 6% | $3,600 | $47,222 | $44,451 | $44,575 |
| HSA, $100 a paycheck | $2,600 | $48,301 | $45,486 | $45,604 |
| Premiums, $150 a paycheck | $3,900 | $47,256 | $44,518 | $44,624 |
| All three | $10,100 | $41,999 | $39,607 | $39,674 |
Read any row against the "None" row. In every state in the table, take-home falls by less than the amount put in, and the HSA row falls by a smaller share of its contribution than the 401(k) row, because the HSA also skips Social Security and Medicare. In New York and Illinois each contribution saves state income tax too, so the drop is smaller there than in Texas, which has no state income tax.
A worked example: 6% to a 401(k)
Take the Texas worker on $60,000, paid biweekly, contributing 6%.
- Each paycheck: take-home goes from $1,938.07 to $1,816.23.
- Federal income tax withheld over the year falls from $5,020 to $4,588.
- Social Security and Medicare over the year stay at $4,590, the same as without the 401(k).
- Over the year, $3,600 goes into the account and take-home falls from $50,390 to $47,222.
The difference between the two is the federal income tax saved: the account gets the full contribution while your paycheck pays only part of it.
The same 6% in New York takes each biweekly check from $1,824.00 to $1,709.64, and in Illinois from $1,829.41 to $1,714.42. Each contribution per check is the same in every state, so the smaller drop in those two states is the state income tax the 401(k) saves.
Swap the 401(k) for an HSA of $100 a paycheck and the per-paycheck take-home is $1,857.72. The Social Security line on each check also drops, from $143.08 to $136.88.
The saving grows with your bracket
The tax a contribution saves depends on the rate that applies to your last dollars of pay, not your average rate. Contributing 6% in Texas:
| Salary | Put in a year | Take-home without | Take-home with 6% to a 401(k) |
|---|---|---|---|
| $40,000 | $2,400 | $34,320 | $32,208 |
| $60,000 | $3,600 | $50,390 | $47,222 |
| $100,000 | $6,000 | $79,180 | $74,500 |
At $40,000 and $60,000 the contribution comes out of pay taxed in the same federal bracket, so it saves the same share of each dollar. At $100,000 it comes out of pay in a higher bracket, and each dollar put in costs noticeably less take-home. In a state with graduated brackets, the state saving grows in the same way: in California, 6% at $100,000 lowers take-home from $72,318 to $68,252.
A 401(k) set as a percentage also follows your pay: it comes out of every check, so a larger check, such as one with overtime, sends more to the account and saves more tax on it. An HSA or premium set as a flat amount per paycheck does not change with the size of the check.
These are withholding figures for one year. The money in a traditional 401(k) is taxed when you take it out later; an HSA used for qualified medical costs is not. That longer-term comparison is outside what a paycheck calculator measures.
Where states differ
Most of the 12 states Netpaysum covers follow the federal treatment for state income tax. Three exceptions change the numbers:
- Pennsylvania does not exclude employee 401(k) deferrals from state taxable compensation. The contribution still lowers your federal income tax, but Pennsylvania's flat 3.07% applies to the full wage. Our Pennsylvania calculator leaves the 401(k) out of its figures, so use the federal effect shown here as your guide.
- California does not exclude HSA contributions from state taxable wages, so an HSA saves federal tax and FICA there but not California tax. Our California calculator leaves the HSA out of its figures.
- New Jersey also does not exclude HSA contributions from state taxable wages. Our New Jersey calculator leaves the HSA out as well.
A 401(k) also does not lower the state payroll programs that some states run on wages: California SDI, New York disability and paid family leave, New Jersey disability, family leave and unemployment insurance, and Pennsylvania unemployment compensation are all worked out on your wage before the 401(k) comes out.
Run your own numbers
- Paycheck calculator: enter your 401(k) percentage, HSA and pre-tax premiums per paycheck; its compare mode shows the same job with two 401(k) settings side by side.
- Hourly paycheck calculator: the same deductions on an hourly rate.
- Bonus tax calculator: what a 401(k) deferral from a bonus does to the bonus check.
For how the federal line is worked out, see federal income tax withholding; for the payroll taxes a 401(k) does not reduce, see Social Security and Medicare tax. To find these deductions on your own stub, see how to read your pay stub.